I've tested a few natural mascaras over the years and was not completely in love with them. Now I'd like to share a fantastic one, Physicians Formula Organic wear 100% Natural Lash Boosting Mascara.
The product is all natural, inexpensive and does a great job of creating fuller, thicker lashes (it's not really for length). I think the unique, flat leaf-shaped tube design is very cute, and the brush (it's quite fat) took a little getting used to, but did a great job of separating my lashes and creating beautiful volume. Note: You need a little patience to get in the inner corners due to the size of the brush, but it is doable.
The produces a healthy, full lash, but it's not going to be an over the top effect. I would put it somewhere between natural (1 coat) to perfect for a complete day-to-night look (2 coats). It didn't smudge, run or flake during the day, and was very easy to remove in the evening.
This is one to pick up...you'll like it and can feel great about the ingredients you're adding to your lashes daily! - RLB
Go--> Available on Ulta.com